There’s been a lot of talk around town lately concerning the city of Atlanta and how good of a sports city Atlanta is. In fact, I’ve heard on many occasions that Atlanta is the worst sports city in the country. It’s true that Atlanta sports hasn’t experienced a whole lot of prosperity as of late. The Braves aren’t winning pennants anymore. One of the few things the Falcons have won lately is a coin flip to give them the third pick in the upcoming NFL draft, following a dismal season. And it’s safe to say that the Hawks and Thrashers aren’t looking forward to championship runs anytime soon. But is it accurate to say that Atlanta is the worst sports city in America?
To examine this topic, let’s look at every city in the country that has all four major sports; football, basketball, baseball and hockey. Giving a little bit of geographical latitude to cities like Boston (the Patriots play in Foxboro, not Boston) and Dallas (the Rangers are in Arlington, not Dallas), there are 12 cities that meet the criteria of having all four major sports. By comparing Atlanta, Miami, New York City, Philadelphia, Washington D.C., Boston, Dallas, Chicago, Detroit, Minneapolis, Denver and Phoenix using their teams’ winning percentage, we can take a look at where Atlanta stands. We can answer the question, statistically speaking, of whether or not Atlanta is the worst sports city in the country.
Winning percentage was calculated for every team in each of these cities for the last three seasons. The 2007 season for the NBA and NHL hasn’t been completed yet, so their current standings were used. Take a look at the standings for 2007 and for the last three years combined.
2007 (Team - Winning Percentage)
- Boston - .651
- Detroit - .609
- Phoenix - .577
- Dallas - .559
- Denver - .553
- Philadelphia - .526
- New York City - .515
- Chicago - .476
- Atlanta - .476
- D.C. - .474
- Minneapolis - .457
- Miami - .379
2005 - 2007 (Team - Winning Percentage)
- Detroit - .604
- Dallas - .592
- Boston - .538
- Phoenix - .534
- New York City - .530
- Denver - .523
- Philadelphia - .506
- Chicago - .501
- Minneapolis - .498
- Atlanta - .484
- Miami - .479
- D.C. - .469
The numbers look bleak. For the last three years, Atlanta has suffered through a sub .500 record. Overall, the four teams combined are 463-494 and have only made it to post season play twice (the 2005 Braves and the 2006-07 Thrashers). With that kind of three year history, you can see why Atlanta sports fans are a little on edge.
However, Atlanta fans can take solace in the fact that they don’t live in Miami or Washington D.C.

Aaron Hanks